Sweet and Spicy Crock Pot Wings are incredibly simple to make. Use your favorite wing sauce, mustard, or spicy jam to make these crock pot wings your own!
For Tim, a game-watching party isn’t really complete without a plate of wings. Buffalo, BBQ or some other fun flavor, as long as there are wings, he is happy.
That’s not to say the sauce isn’t important.
The sauce is (almost) the reason for the wings. So, it has to be perfect.
With Tim’s wing passion, we were surprised when we realized that we had actually never cooked wings at home.
I think some of the reasoning was that we don’t like to venture into deep-fried territory. But, like with nearly everything deep-fried, there is a way around the vat of oil.
In the case of wings, there are a few options: grilled, baked or baked and simmered, to name just three.
How To Make Crock Pot Wings
Since game day parties require food that can be kept at eating temperature for a couple of hours, we went with the baked and simmered option because it let us make use of our crock pot. (Like yesterday’s Pulled Pork.)
Baking the wings before tossing them in the crock pot with the sauce, locks the juices inside, similar to searing the meat, resulting in incredibly moist wings. It also crisps up the skin, so it doesn’t get overly soggy in the sauce. (It won’t stay crisp though, so if you’re looking for that crisp skin, we’d recommend using the baked-only method.)
Sweet and Spicy Crock Pot Wings
So what sauce did we pick for this first endeavor?
One of the #10DaysofTailgate sponsors, El Diablo Hot and Spicy Mustard, generously sent each of the bloggers a sample pack of their six mustard varieties. (UPDATE– Unfortunately, it seems as if El Diablo is no longer producing spicy mustards. Use your favorite wing sauce, mustard, or spicy jam instead.)
If you’re not big on spicy food, these crock pot wings are the way to go. The spice mellows during the extended cooking time, leaving you with a sweet and tangy mustard sauce that carries a fraction of the initial heat.
Crock Pot Wings are incredibly simple to make and a sweet mango mustard sauce makes these wings irresistible.
Yield: 3 lbs of wings
- 3 lbs chicken wings, thawed if frozen
- ½ c your favorite wing sauce, mustard, or spicy jam
- 2 Tbsp honey
- Preheat your oven to 375F.
- Place the wings on an aluminum foil lined baking sheet. Bake wings for 20 minutes.
- Remove the wings from the oven and place in a 2-3 qt crock pot.
- Mix mustard and honey in a small bowl. Pour over wings and mix to coat.
- Cook on high for 2-2 ½ hours or on low for 3-4 hours, until wings are tender. If possible, stir occasionally to ensure the wings are evenly coated with the sauce.
DISCLOSURE: We received samples of El Diablo Hot and Spicy Mustard that we used in this recipe. We were not compensated for our time. As always, all opinions are our own.
Here’s what the team brought to today’s game!
- Cheesy Maple Leaf Farm Duck Bacon Oven Chips by Making Miracles
- Mango-Mustard Crock Pot Wings by Curious Cuisiniere
- Cheesy Pulled Pork Egg Rolls by From Gate to Plate
- Herbed Deviled Eggs by Culinary Adventures with Camilla
- Amaretto Spiced Apple Cider by The Spiffy Cookie
- Roasted Red Pepper Hummus by Debbi Does Dinner Healthy
- Green and Gold Grilled Chicken (Green Curry and Pineapple) by Cheese Curd In Paradise
- Turducken Meatballs by Miss Laura’s Kitchen
- Meaty “Beast Mode” Baked Beans by OnTheMove-In the Galley
- Chicken Apple Bratwurst Burgers by A Kitchen Hoor’s Adventures
- Grilled Green Beans, Mushrooms, and Duck Bacon by The Pajama Chef